Answering service vs voicemail: what each one really costs.

Voicemail is free and an answering service is not. Here is what the research says about each, and how a contractor can work out which costs more.

Voicemail costs nothing a month and an answering service costs a few hundred dollars or more. On paper that is an easy choice. The trouble is that voicemail's real cost never appears on a bill.

This is a straight comparison of an answering service vs voicemail for a trade shop, including the cases where voicemail is perfectly fine.

What the research says about voicemail

Invoca found that fewer than 3% of callers who are sent to voicemail leave a message. The same research found that 27% of calls to home services businesses are not answered at all. Put those together and the picture is clear: a missed call is, nearly every time, a caller who has moved on.

Why callers do not leave messages

  • They have a problem now and want it dealt with now.
  • They found you in a list of search results, and the next name is one tap away.
  • They do not know when, or whether, you will call back.
  • Many people simply do not use voicemail any more.
  • For an emergency, leaving a message feels like doing nothing.

What voicemail is still good for

  • Existing customers who know you and will wait.
  • Suppliers, inspectors and others who must reach you specifically.
  • Very low call volumes, where you return every call within the hour.
  • A backstop behind another system.

If that describes most of your calls, voicemail may be all you need.

Answering service vs voicemail, side by side

  • Monthly cost. Voicemail: nothing. Answering service: a monthly fee.
  • Who the caller reaches. Voicemail: a recording. Answering service: a person.
  • New customers. Voicemail: nearly all hang up. Answering service: they are helped.
  • Emergencies. Voicemail: wait until you check. Answering service: put through to you.
  • Booking. Voicemail: none. Answering service: on your calendar, if you choose one that books.
  • Your evening. Voicemail: returning calls. Answering service: yours.

Work out what voicemail costs you

  1. Pull last month's call log from your carrier.
  2. Count the calls that went unanswered during the hours you work.
  3. Count how many of those left a message or called back.
  4. The rest are lost. Multiply them by your average job value and by the share of calls you usually win.

As an example with made up numbers, so use your own: 15 lost calls, a $350 average job and half of them won is $2,625 a month. That is the monthly cost of free voicemail for that shop.

If you are keeping voicemail for now

  • Record the greeting yourself, with your company name.
  • Say when you will call back, and mean it.
  • Tell emergency callers what to do.
  • Turn on an automatic text to missed callers. See missed call text back for contractors.
  • Check messages between every job, not at the end of the day.

The other kind of bad answering

Be careful not to swap voicemail for a service that only takes messages. You will have paid to move the callback from your voicemail to your text inbox. Invoca found that 76% of people stop doing business with a company after one bad experience, and "someone will call you back" during an emergency is one. The gain comes from the job being booked on the call.

What Ground Control does instead

We answer as your company and book the job into your calendar. A real person in the USA answers from 7am to 6pm, and AI is on the line every other hour of the year. Emergencies are put through to you or your on call tech. Plans start at $597+ a month, flat, with no setup fee. On a 30 minute call we go through your real call log and tell you honestly whether the lost calls justify it. If they do not, we will say so. Book a 30 minute call and we will go through your actual call log with you.

Common questions

Is voicemail enough for a contractor?

For a shop with very few calls, mostly from existing customers, it can be. For a shop missing calls from new customers most days, voicemail loses nearly all of them.

What percentage of callers leave a voicemail?

Invoca found that fewer than 3% of callers who are sent to voicemail leave a message.

How much business does voicemail cost?

Count the missed calls that never called back in a month, then multiply by your average job value and the share of calls you normally win. That figure is the monthly cost.

Is a message taking answering service better than voicemail?

Slightly, because a person answers. But the customer still has to wait for a callback, so many still go elsewhere. A service that books the job during the call performs far better.

How can I improve my voicemail in the meantime?

Record a personal greeting with your company name, say when you will call back, tell emergency callers what to do, and send an automatic text to missed callers.

See what your missed calls are worth.

Thirty minutes on the phone. We go through your real call log, and if it is not worth fixing we will say so.

Book a 30 minute call
Keep reading
Who we work with

How many calls did
you miss last week?

Most shop owners do not know, and the number is always worse than the guess. Give us thirty minutes. We will go through your actual call log, tell you what those missed rings were worth, and if it is a fit we will get you signed up on that call. If it is not worth fixing, we will say so and you have lost half an hour.

NEW HAMPSHIRE · MASSACHUSETTS · MAINE · VERMONT · ANSWERED BY A TRADESMAN